appConfigEntityId

bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

isVideo

articlePageQuery

article

articleSchemaContent

content

hooksArticlePageAdvertisementConfigArticle

appConfig

filter

json

liveArticle

A doctor was sentenced to 18 months’ jail on Thursday for administering a substance to a woman as part of an aesthetic treatment that killed her.
The ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) was administered too quickly and at too high a concentration, causing 31-year-old Lau Li Ting to develop EDTA toxicity, which led to cardiac arrest and death.
Dr Chan Bingyi later concealed the fact that he had administered EDTA to the victim from her family, paramedics and doctors, in what the judge said was “deplorable conduct” done for his own self-preservation.
The 38-year-old Singaporean had contested one charge of committing a negligent act not amounting to culpable homicide in causing Lau’s death, but was convicted.
Lau, whom the prosecution described as a healthy woman, had visited Revival Medical & Aesthetics Centre in Bras Basah in March 2019 for aesthetic treatment.
In his account to the Ministry of Health (MOH) after the incident, Chan said Lau wanted to improve the fine lines on her forehead.
Chan initially recommended a treatment different from EDTA and laser for her pores.
He claimed that Lau asked if he provided chelation therapy which she had undergone with another doctor.
Chelation therapy involves the intravenous administration of EDTA to treat heavy metal toxicity.
EDTA is a powerful chemical agent which acts as a chelator or binding agent that suppresses chemical activity.
The Society of Aesthetic Medicine (Singapore) previously stated that chelation therapy was not a field within aesthetic medicine, but was advocated by “some wellness promoting clinics” for use on healthy patients, with the belief that heavy metals consumed in daily diets contribute to poor health and premature ageing.
Chan told MOH that he told Lau she was not suitable to undergo chelation therapy, but she “insisted” as she was happy with the outcome previously.
After Chan administered the treatment with the EDTA injection, Lau stopped talking and he realised she was having a seizure. She later died.
At trial, Chan’s defence lawyers Adrian Wee and Lynette Chang from Lighthouse Law argued that Lau could have died from other reasons, such as the consumption of slimming products.
The defence also said that the use of EDTA was not expressly prohibited by MOH at the time of the offence.
An MOH circular had requested all hospitals to cease providing chelation therapy, but it was not issued to private clinics and Chan was made aware of this circular only after Lau died and MOH provided him a copy, the lawyers said.
They added that Chan had attempted to resuscitate the victim, called for an ambulance and went to the hospital multiple times.
Senior District Judge Ong Hian Sun found that Chan’s acts were the sole and direct cause of Lau’s death.
He said it was not mitigatory that Lau had not suffered harm in her previous treatment, or that Chan had carried out similar treatments to other patients without any harm.
Judge Ong said Chan knew the risks, including death, associated with chelation treatment but did not take any precautions to ensure Lau was a suitable candidate for it.
In a doctor-patient relationship, the patient’s life and well-being are at the mercy of the doctor treating her, the judge said.
He said Chan had “clearly betrayed” the trust imposed in him by agreeing to administer EDTA on Lau and he was motivated by monetary gain.
Chan did not take the necessary safeguards in the procedure and had not undergone any proper training for the administration of EDTA, the treatment of which was prohibited by MOH, Judge Ong said.
His conduct after Lau collapsed was also relevant as he had “wilfully” chosen to conceal the EDTA treatment from her family members, paramedics and treating doctors, depriving them of critical life-saving information, the judge said.
Chan had also deliberately omitted keeping proper clinical notes about the procedure, knowing he had administered a prohibited substance which caused her collapse.
For his own self-preservation, he also did not preserve any of the items used in the treatment at the time.
Chan is still registered as a medical practitioner on MOH’s registry.
He will be appealing against his conviction and sentence.
For causing death by a negligent act not amounting to culpable homicide, he could have been jailed for up to two years, fined or both.
This story was first published by CNA


Singapore doctor jailed over woman’s death during beauty treatment

With proposed FTA, Asean set to be ‘central’ in Canada’s trade diversification

High stakes, low odds: why 1MDB’s Jho Low unlikely to receive Trump pardon

Iran war pushes Asia’s Gulf migrants to use stablecoins for remittances

Singapore

A Singaporean doctor received 18 months’ jail for a patient’s death during a beauty treatment. Photo: Shutterstock

AI disinformation? Singapore accused in pro-China videos of being ‘ungrateful’

A WeChat video saying Singapore is the most miserable country in the world. Photo: WeChat

A WeChat video saying Singapore “treats the US as a father figure”. Photo: WeChat

An oil tanker refuels a container vessel at Pasir Panjang port terminal in Singapore. China is the city state’s largest trading partner. Photo: AFP

People in the Raffles Place financial business district in Singapore. A poll shows most Singaporeans would choose Beijing over Washington as a strategic partner if forced to pick one. Photo: AFP

Singaporeans refute lack of hunger stereotype, warn of ‘self-fulfilling bias’ over jobs

People visit the Merlion statue in Singapore. A recruiter’s comment on the lack of hunger among Singaporean workers compared with their foreign counterparts has sparked a fierce debate. Photo: AFP

People at the Raffles Place financial business district in Singapore. More workers in Singapore are facing challenges ranging from offshoring to artificial intelligence. Photo: AFP

A worker checks a wafer chip in a plant in Singapore. Singapore’s stability and high living standards have lulled some local workers into complacency, according to industry experts. Photo: Reuters

Pedestrians cross a traffic junction along Orchard Road. Singaporean workers are increasingly looking for purpose in their careers beyond pay, according to analysts. Photo: AFP

Singapore’s Lawrence Wong urges global push for upholding international sea laws

Singapore’s Prime Minister Lawrence Wong at the SGLaw200 Youth Forum held at the Singapore Management University on Wednesday. Photo: Jacky Ho for SGLaw200

A worker walks past the liquefied natural gas tanker ETYFA-Prometheas in the Malacca Strait on April 15. Photo: EPA

News

Asia

Southeast Asia

A judge slammed Chan Bingyi’s ‘deplorable’ choice to hide the truth from the victim’s family and paramedics to protect himself


A judge slammed Chan Bingyi’s ‘deplorable’ choice to hide the truth from the victim’s family and paramedics to protect himself.


Crime

Singapore doctor jailed over woman’s death during beauty treatment

.css-1c6uqr6{color:inherit;font-weight:inherit;font-size:inherit;font-family:inherit;line-height:inherit;overflow-wrap:break-word;}A judge slammed Chan Bingyi’s ‘deplorable’ choice to hide the truth from the victim’s family and paramedics to protect himself

A judge slammed Chan Bingyi’s ‘deplorable’ choice to hide the truth from the victim’s family and paramedics to protect himself