appConfigEntityId

bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

isVideo

articlePageQuery

article

articleSchemaContent

content

hooksArticlePageAdvertisementConfigArticle

appConfig

filter

json

liveArticle

Denise Tsang

The takeover of a prime venue at an exclusive Hong Kong sports club in Central has been postponed following opposition from some members, who have also called on management to scrap the plan entirely, the South China Morning Post has learned.
A source said that following a meeting involving members of the Hong Kong Golf & Tennis Academy (HKGTA), the date of the merger of operations for its Town Club at Central’s New World Tower with private members’ club Carlyle & Co would be pushed back by two months.
According to an internal memo issued by Carlyle & Co and seen by the SCMP, the takeover would take effect on August 8.
As recently as last Friday evening, HKGTA had told the SCMP that it would proceed on June 8.
“This is not just a small win. Holding off for two months after all these high-profile adverts is quite big,” a meeting attendee said. “We hope we will be able to arrive at a good middle ground at the end.”
The latest development stalls previous plans to allow members of the two clubs to use their facilities reciprocally.
On Saturday, the SCMP reported that some HKGTA members had deemed the takeover unfair as they had paid up to HK$2.68 million (US$342,200) for their memberships, whereas Carlyle & Co’s fees were significantly less, as low as under HK$50,000.

HKGTA members also argued that the two clubs catered to different clientele.
They said the Town Club was patronised by more professionals, including lawyers, bankers, doctors and corporate executives, whereas Carlyle & Co’s younger membership base included key opinion leaders, entrepreneurs and those in the insurance and service industries.
In addition to its venue in Central, the HKGTA has a club in Sai Kung. Carlyle & Co is based at the Rosewood Hong Kong hotel in Tsim Sha Tsui.
The HKGTA is part of New World Development, and the Rosewood is owned by Chow Tai Fook Enterprises, controlled by the family of tycoon Henry Cheng Kar-shun. Rosewood is headed by his daughter, Sonia Cheng Chi-man.
Sources said the recent meeting saw more than 70 HKGTA members join remotely, with the management of the HKGTA, the Rosewood and Carlyle & Co also present.
The latter included Rosewood chief operating officer Andrew Ingham, Carlyle & Co global vice-president Jonathan Frolich and HKGTA general manager Andrew Yang.
Another HKGTA member said the management’s decision to postpone the merger appeared to be aimed at buying time.
“As to what will happen next, it is not known,” the member said.
Another HKGTA patron said some perpetual members had urged management to abandon the proposal to protect their rights.
Some also threatened to take the matter to the Consumer Council and other relevant authorities, according to the patron.
“There is a plan for HKGTA management to consult or seek consensus from 20 perpetual members, but why do these members get to speak for all perpetual members?” the patron said.
Another source said that since Adrian Cheng Chi-kong, the elder brother of Sonia Cheng, stepped down as CEO of New World, the Town Club had been managed by her team.
The situation meant that New World had effectively become a landlord instead, the source said.
The SCMP has reached out to the HKGTA and Rosewood for comment.


Hong Kong urged to shift from role as ‘superconnector’ to ‘value-adder’

Tourist arrivals up 10% year on year in April, driven by Hong Kong Sevens

3 ways to build Hong Kong’s yacht economy beyond infrastructure

Why did Hongkongers queue round the clock for a new watch?

Hong Kong economy

Takeover of Hong Kong Golf & Tennis Academy’s Central club postponed by 2 months

The merger of operations at the HKGTA’s Town Club in Central earlier sparked a backlash among members. Photo: Handout

HKGTA members have argued that the two clubs cater to different clientele. Photo: Handout

Hong Kong Golf & Tennis Academy members reject Central service takeover by Carlyle & Co

Carlyle & Co, a private members’ club, will take over the operations of the Hong Kong Golf & Tennis Academy’s  Town Club in Central on June 8. Photo: Handout

The 18,000-square-metre HKGTA Town Club is located on the 24th floor of New World Tower in Central. Photo: Handout

Hong Kong Aberdeen marina project attracts local and overseas interest

The Aberdeen marina project has drawn strong interest from yacht operators and developers as Hong Kong pushes its luxury tourism ambitions. Photo: Jelly Tse

Jonathan Sit, regional general manager of SUTL Enterprise’s marina division, pictured at the Singapore Yachting Festival. Photo: Aileen Chuang

ExclusiveTakeover of Hong Kong Golf & Tennis Academy’s Central club postponed by 2 months

Source says delay of merger with Carlyle & Co follows meeting of HKGTA members

.css-1c6uqr6{color:inherit;font-weight:inherit;font-size:inherit;font-family:inherit;line-height:inherit;overflow-wrap:break-word;}Source says delay of merger with Carlyle & Co follows meeting of HKGTA members

Source says delay of merger with Carlyle & Co follows meeting of HKGTA members